Religious Law vs. Civic Law

A post from Three Jews, Four Opinions makes some interesting points. Mostly it asks the question that while Jewish law clearly forbids homosexuality, does that mean that Jews should vote to ban homosexual marriage in California law? The overwhelming answer is no.

This gets to the heart of my frustration of Christian intolerance. While Jews have some very crazy religious laws, they don’t seek to codify any of those laws into civic statute. Christians, on the other hand, believe that if something is immoral it should be illegal. I’ve often been inclined to think that it’s the very nature of the religious to attempt to impose religion into government, but on further reflection, I think it’s just Christians. Muslims certainly do this in Islamic nations, but I’ve never seen an American Muslim make any real effort to include their crazy laws into American law.

And that right there is intolerance: a refusal to tolerate the differing beliefs, rights and practices of others. Why, if Jesus preached tolerance, are Christians such an intolerant lot?

The linked post above also basically makes the point that I’ve made all along: Government has no place in marriage.

Another night in New York

I’m becoming increasingly annoyed with my employer. If anyone in the company knows what’s going on, they’re not telling me. Still no word at all about whether I’m going to fly a Dash here in a couple weeks or not.

Kelsey decided to rearrange his schedule so that the Nachzen kids could hang out last night. I cooked chicken, mashed potatoes, onions, artichoke and asparagus. We drank several bottles of wine and then Mario Carted for a few hours. I’m not very good at video games, but it’s always reassuring to know that Sydney will bring up the rear for me. I actually did very well, and after every race the Nintendo said, “You won!” It doesn’t lie. We all spent the night in Wa-Hi, because trains late at night are annoying. Sydney looks funny in Kelsey’s clothes.

I flew what’s likely my last flight in a jet. It took a little work to get back into the swing of things after a month of not flying. My final landing in JFK was a real winner, I think the ground crews are out there now filling the two potholes I left in 22R.

I’m just about to go collect my dry cleaning and go sit ready reserve at the airport tonight from 7pm until at least midnight. Potentially as late as 3am. I’m doing the same thing tomorrow night as well.

Change at Jamaica for the local train to Babylon.

There’s been a rather unfortunate change in the configuration of the crew room–the TV is now in the main room instead of the little back room. The only internet connection is in the same room as the TV. Fortunately, I’ve got headphones. There are few things in the world I find more obnoxious than CNN.

Joanna and I went to Dallas to see The Magnetic Fields on a whimsy of mine, that had something to do with Rachel. We could have seen The Magnetic Fields in New York or Denver, which would have been more convenient, but then we wouldn’t have gotten to see Rachel, Kate and JR and meet Joseph. Seeing The Magnetic Fields in Dallas didn’t really seem to be one of those things I had any choice about, despite the fact that I’m the one who made the choice. I’m jealous that Joanna got to eat at Breadwinner’s and I didn’t.

I’m still scheduled to start a 5-day trip tomorrow. This is good news, and I hope it will re-endear me to the job. It’s been so long since I’ve actually flown, I’m forgetting why I ever thought it would be a good idea. It’s really starting to wear me down. I took the midnight DEN-JFK this morning. It’s a silly way to get to work, but means an extra day at home. It’s hot and icky in New York (okay, a whopping 70 degrees, but compared to 40 in Colorado, it’s hot and icky). I crossed Flatbush in a crosswalk, with “the white man” as Liz would say, and about halfway across the street, traffic turning right decided to honk at me and started gesturing to the flashing red hand (“slappy” for those who speak Liz) as though I no longer had the right of way. I raised my hand in a, “What the hell?” gesture and walked slower. It’s that sort of thing, along with the dog shit I discovered on my shoe later that make me hate New York. The love/hate relationship is a delicate balance highly influenced by the amount of time I spend in the city. Lately, I’ve spent way too much time here, and today is a day that I hate New York.

My last 24 hours looked something like this: At 10pm last night, Jonah drove me to the DEN airport. (I was too tired to drive my car back on Tuesday.) I got to the airport at about 11:15pm, and on the plane at about 11:40pm for an 11:50pm departure. I got a middle seat, but at least it was in the “more leg room” section. I was only able to fit my bag in an overhead bin at the back of plane, even though I was sitting in the front, and even that required serious overhead bin mojo, which obviously I now possess.

The flight wasn’t too bad, though I wasn’t able to sleep very well. I got off the plane in New York around 5am. I rode the AirTrain to the LIRR, where I had to buy a peak ticket. I live off-peak, but my going “home” happened to be at the same time and same direction as the rest of New York going to work. I got off the train and walked a mile. My leather jacket was miserably hot and an unwelcome burden. I should have just left it in Jonah’s car, but I’m guessing I’ll want it when I drive home next week. I carried my leather jacket and heavy bag up to Sydney’s 3rd floor apartment, inflated my air mattress and fell asleep around 7am.

I woke up at 11:59am to my phone ringing. Crew tracking jumped the gun by 1 minute, but unfortunately I can’t read the clock on my phone while it’s ringing, so I didn’t know that when I answered it. I knew exactly what the crew tracker was going to say. I could have avoided the phone conversation by clicking the “I’ve been notified” button on my schedule online to acknowledge the Noon-10pm ready reserve, but if I did that, I’d have shorted myself 1.5 hours of sleep. I’m not required to answer my phone until I go on duty at noon, at which point they’ll tell me to be at the airport for ready reserve, but they have to give me 1.5 hours to get to the airport. Sometimes they forget and call me up to half an hour late, but not today. Also, they decided they still wanted the full 10 hours out of me, and instead of my usual 1200-2200 shift, they assigned me a 1330-2330 shift.

And so now it’s 8pm, and I’m at the airport, too tired to read my book with 3.5 hours of sitting left to go.

All this, so that I can get paid to fly an airplane. I keep waiting for the asymptotic deadline where I find out if I can live at home and fly the Dash.

But I get to fly tomorrow. Things will be better tomorrow.

Thanks for your patience.

First they said we would find out about the displacements on October 6. And then they said it wouldn’t be until October 10. And then October 17th. And now, they’re saying it will be October 20 or later. Seriously, it’s not like people are trying to make plans for the future or anything. You’re not welcome to my patience. You’ve exhausted my patience.

So, I won’t know anything until sometime after Monday, October 20, now. They’ve also currently put me on reserve until midnight in JFK on Nov 2nd, and then in training at 0800 in PHX on Nov 3rd. Brilliant, just brilliant.

Vote for Life, Vote Obama.

I received an email today which normally I probably would have summarily deleted without giving it much thought, but I was asked to comment on it. Here’s the whole thing in its entirety:

Words of Warning and Hope
by
Lori Kalner

Dear Friends,

It becomes more difficult for me to write to you these days with a difficult time of dialysis as diabetes advances. Now I must write at least this one last time. Bodie and Brock are gracious and let my voice of warning be heard.

I was a young girl in Germany and lived through difficult times. We have since then had a wonderful life. The world, as difficult as it has been, at least for many years remembered what happened politically in Germany with the Depression in the 1930s. You remember how it began and thus progressed with the horrors of war which followed.
The battle was at the beginning a Spiritual battle.
You have read some parts of my story in the Zion Covenant, from growing up in Germany in the days when evil men prevailed and TRUTH was turned upside down. White became black through a barrage of propaganda and constant repetition of lies against those who spoke the truth.

Here is my warning to all: Perhaps it will be my last warning. (I wake up each day surprised that I am still here and not in heaven with those who wait for me!)
America and the whole world hangs in the balance now. I believe that America will stand or fall depending on who is elected President this year.
Good Americans, like the good Germans of my youth, may think that the issues of their nation center around the economy. I tell you now that the fate of the greatest nation on earth does not depend on money.
Every issue must only be judged worthy and true by the Word of God. Prosperity comes to a nation and a people who serves the Lord first. That is a basic spiritual principle which is seen in every book of Holy Scripture.
“If My people, who are called by My Name, will humble themselves, and turn from their wicked ways, then I will hear from heaven and will forgive their sin and heal their land.” (2 Chronicles 7:14)

This is where the healing of America begins: Friend, you must begin with examination of your own life first and the confession of your sins.
Then pray for your nation. Ask yourself now: who supports the rights of the unborn babies and also of those who are handicapped?
History tells us why this is critical:
In the Germany of my childhood, everyone worried about the economy. Paying bills. Buying bread. Money! And there were 1 million abortions in the year before Hitler came to power. (A drop in the bucket compared to America.) The excuse given for the murder of unborn babies was that economic times were hard. How could a family feed another mouth?
There followed the legalized forced sterilization of parents who had a handicapped child or who were judged “racially impure.”
Next came the legalized euthanasia of those who were handicapped. (An example of who would be killed is the Downs Syndrome child of Sarah Palin. He would have been killed immediately at birth.)
Do we not see such choices carried out with tiny babies being strangled or left to die by abortionists today? Evil advances forward in America by law! This is done with the support of men and women in office who have sold their souls for power.
In those days in Germany all, who were, as I am now, elderly or ill, were gassed. These were all called “useless eaters.”
Christians and Jews who spoke out against this evil were labeled as radical “religious fanatics.” A campaign of false accusation, slander and persecution began, targeting people of faith. It was “unpopular” to speak the TRUTH. (Were these persecuted Christians people like you?) Many were jailed and eventually killed. Some escaped with only their lives.
Finally, by millions, Jews were hunted, imprisoned and killed. You know all this from the Zion Covenant books. I lived it.

Now, today, I hear the words and know the deeds of this Barack Obama and I know that he is a “gifted,” convincing, fellow. He is telling you how bad you have it and saying to Americans he is their messiah and the answer to all problems.
The propaganda machine loves Obama. The power of the media is much greater than in my childhood; a frightening thought.
But here is TRUTH: of all men in the US government this Obama has most strongly encouraged and urged the on-going slaughter of the unborn…”the useless mouths” of America. This slaughter is performed in the name of “A woman’s reproductive rights.”
In the land of my birth, the Holocaust all began with the first step of legalized abortion. Abortion was ENCOURAGED by a downturn in the world economics.
Scripture teaches us the survival of a nation is not about the economy. The only nation which will stand is the nation which follows the Lord and the true teachings of scripture.
I warn you, my dear American friends, with love in my heart and with my last breaths that no man or woman, Protestant or Catholic, can remain in God’s favor or blessing if they vote for this Obama. This is a man who voted four times to leave tiny babies who survived abortions to die!
I know many devout American Catholics in my life and many who have never voted for the Republicans because of tradition. Now I say that you who are Catholic must not follow after this man Obama who is gifted in his words but NOT speaking the TRUE WORDS OF OUR LORD OR THE CHURCH!
You cannot be a true Catholic Christian and vote for Obama. To vote for him is to vote for continued infanticide. To Protestant Christians, I say, you are not a Christian if you support the slaughter of the unborn!
Christianity and abortion are spiritually impossible companions.
Protestants and Catholics MUST UNITE in this battle. The victory must be overwhelming!
Do you feel you cannot vote for Mr. McCain and Mrs. Palin, who are for the LIFE of the unborn and handicapped? If you cannot support these leaders, then for the sake of your soul, I, who have seen the spiritual destruction of many good people, Protestants and Catholics, urge you NOT TO VOTE for Obama or anyone who does not support protection of LIFE!
For all those American politicians who have the chance to change the course toward destruction, I who have been witness to national and worldwide tragedy, urge you protect those in your society who are the most helpless. Publicly deny your support of Obama. According to 2 Chronicles 7:14 you must turn your life around for the sake of your soul and your country!
To those politicians who use “FAITH” to get votes while they follow the path of destruction, I must speak this warning: “God will not be mocked.”
If you, Christian, can vote, and if you can encourage others to vote, then you must VOTE FOR LIFE.
In the judgment of heaven, there is no other choice but LIFE and protection of the innocent for a Christian.

I am thankful to Bodie and Brock for letting me be heard once more. They agree with history and with the Truth of scripture. Most of my generation is gone now. You who are taking control of the world have a fight ahead of you as the memory of our peril dims. I have heard and listened closely to the voices of Sarah Palin and John McCain, and my spirit bears witness that they speak truth and are the true Hope-Bearers of your generation. Sarah is a true Deborah. Pray for her and her family and also for John McCain. You must all remember what happened to us and not repeat the same mistake of apathy.

If I cannot write to you again I pray we will meet in heaven and you will tell me I helped you encourage others to do the right thing for the sake of your soul and for the nation.

God bless you,
Lori Kalner

In addition to being blatantly false, offensive to many Christians I know, and offensive to me as a human being, I think it’s potentially useful for us to understand the warped peculiarities that appear to affect the thinking of some of the voting members of our society.

The tone of the letter is one of abject fear, which warms my heart. It indicates the author has belatedly realized that the American people have (also belatedly) taken note that their continued political apathy has wrought the codification of fringe religious ideals. While the U.S. is (for better, or much likely worse) a nation comprised primarily of Christians, the conservative Christians have made great strides this last decade in curbing the very freedom that makes our nation special. I think that (in spite of my overall poor opinion of the voting public), freedom will prevail over religious oppression, and Kalner is afraid of this as well. She hopes to spread her fear, much as the Republicans have done of late, to motivate easily-frightened people to take her side.

The premise is that as a Christian, one should vote for John McCain because Barack Obama “supports abortion.” This is a patently false statement. Barack Obama is outspoken against abortion and is the first democrat to list as a specific goal his plans to, “reduce the number of abortions in the united states.”

What’s at stake here are two very different approaches to reducing abortion. Kalner presumably hopes that McCain will appoint Supreme Court justices who are likely to overturn Roe v. Wade so that states can make abortion illegal. Obama, on the other hand, is opposed to making abortion illegal and looks to other means for reducing abortion. Sex education as well as better access to contraception appears to be the cornerstone of his plan and this makes sense. People have abortions because they didn’t want to get pregnant in the first place. If you attack the problem (risky sexual behavior), then presumably the symptom (abortions) will go away.

The letter states that Obama voted against the partial-birth abortion ban in Illinois. (In truth, he didn’t vote against it, he simply declined to vote, which is a de facto vote against.) Why did he vote against it? The bill included language that would essentially criminalize all abortions (even those that aren’t partial-birth) and included no concept about the life of the mother. He has stated that he supports state level partial-birth abortion bans, but only when they are are sanely written.

And this is where I’m dumb-founded. Obama is against life? In the case where a mother is forced to chose between her own life or the potential life of her fetus, Obama thinks the mother should be allowed to make that choice. McCain would like to criminalize the actions of a woman who makes the choice to save her own life.

I’d counter that the criminalization of abortion is an anti-life viewpoint. Criminalizing abortion will in no way cause people to stop having abortions. If it’s illegal in some states, people will simply travel to other states. If it’s illegal in all states, people will either leave the country, self-abort, or resort to extremely risky back-alley abortions. This is not mere conjecture on my part. Abortion used to be illegal in this country, and it’s pretty easy to see what happened back then.

The more frustrating aspect of the letter is that it implies that her reader (presumably a Christian) should vote for McCain simply because Obama does not support efforts to criminalize abortion. Seriously? This issue should be at the forefront of the Christian voter’s mind?

I have a special distaste for single-issue voters. This country is a republic. As a republic, the idea is that we are governed by elected representatives. The proper decision-making process as a responsible republican citizen is to vote for that representative who, in your opinion, will make the best choices for the country at large. In actuality, people tend to vote a bit more egocentrically and pick that representative whom they think will make choices that most benefit the voter himself. Assuming a reasonably large percentage of the population votes, the end result should, hopefully, be similar. (They’re not, but that’s a topic for a different time.)

The bottom line is that if you, as a United States citizen are voting for or against any particular candidate on the basis of abortion as Kalner has urged that you do, I think you’re being irresponsible, short-sighted and particularly dim-witted.

Now I’d like to just briefly address the offensive nature of the letter. I’m no Christian, but I’ve got a pretty good grasp of both Protestant and Catholic theology. The letter is, at it’s heart, terribly un-Christian. It states that, “no man or woman, Protestant or Catholic, can remain in God’s favor or blessing if they vote for this Obama.” This statement is not only absurd, it’s blasphemous! I suspect this woman meets multiple criteria for being a false prophet.

Obama has made a great effort to show he’s a Christian. McCain, unlike Obama, has made no real effort to endorse Christian values, and does not even publicly claim to be a Christian! If you look at the important Christian issues, I think you might find that anti-abortion viewpoints are perhaps not the most important.

Let’s talk about issues that a president can directly affect. Let’s talk about the pro-Life Obama. Let’s talk about the lives Obama has proposed to save from the pointless, expensive and deadly war that war-mongering John McCain would like prolong. Let’s talk about the lives Obama will save with a health care plan that might (though very well might not) work. Let’s talk about the lives that Obama proposes we save from poverty through education. That is, if you must talk about lives. Personally, I’d rather talk about freedom, because without freedom, what is a life worth living? “Give me liberty, or give me death,” sound familiar? Obama promises to protect the freedom my country was founded upon where McCain promises to steadily erode that freedom and plunge this country further into the mess created by Dubya and his army of freedom-haters.

I do agree with this statement: “If you, Christian, can vote, and if you can encourage others to vote, then you must VOTE FOR LIFE.” If you must vote for Life, please do so: Vote Obama!